Fichaloto

Blog Data protection

GPS and fingerprint clock-in: where the line sits

8 min read

The two questions sound alike and have very different answers. Location can be used under conditions that are reasonable. Fingerprints are special category data, and the bar is far higher.

Location: yes, with conditions

Spanish data protection law allows geolocation for the exercise of the employer's control functions, with one requirement that leaves no room for interpretation: employees and their representatives must be informed expressly, clearly and unambiguously, and in advance. Under the GDPR alone, the same facts land in the same place through necessity and proportionality.

The line that decides it

Checking where a clock-in happened is one thing. Knowing where a person is during the working day is another, and it is the one that turns time tracking into monitoring.

A point captured at the instant of the entry, stored with that entry, answers the legitimate question — this clock-in happened where it was supposed to — and answers nothing else. A continuous trail answers a great many questions nobody authorised you to ask. If your tool stores the second kind, the problem is not your privacy notice. It is the design.

  • Location at the moment of the entry, never between entries.
  • A radius rather than a precise coordinate: whether the entry fell inside the declared area is enough.
  • No movement history, because none of it is needed for a working-time record.
  • The same notice for everybody, managers included.

Fingerprints and faces are a different category

Biometric data used to identify somebody is special category data under article 9 of the GDPR. Processing is prohibited unless one of the article 9 exceptions applies, and the two routes people try both have a problem.

  • Consent in an employment relationship is weak: it is hard to call it freely given when the person asking signs your pay, and if it is not freely given it is not consent.
  • A legal obligation to record working time is not, by itself, a basis for processing biometrics. The duty is to record hours, not to record them with a fingerprint, and where a less intrusive method works equally well you are expected to use it.

The June 2026 ruling, read correctly

Spain's Audiencia Nacional, in judgment 367/2026 of 30 June 2026, annulled the Spanish data protection authority's guidance on biometric presence control, published on 23 November 2023.

The ground was procedural: given its content and its external effects, the document should have been issued as a binding circular rather than as non-binding guidance. The court did not rule on whether biometric clock-in is lawful.

So the practical consequence is not the one that travelled. Annulling guidance authorises nothing: the GDPR is untouched, article 9 is where it was, and what weakens is the set of penalties that leaned substantially on that guidance. Penalties that stand on their own — no legal basis, no justification — still stand.

If you are going to use biometrics anyway

  • An identified article 9 basis, written down and defensible.
  • A necessity and proportionality assessment that explains why a less intrusive method will not do.
  • A data protection impact assessment beforehand, not afterwards.
  • A real alternative for anybody who declines, with no detriment attached to declining.

What we do, so it is on the record

Fichaloto has no fingerprint and no face recognition, and neither is on the roadmap. What it has is an address declared by each person, a check at the moment of the clock-in, and a flag when an entry lands far from that address — reviewed by a human and closed with a written reason. No trail between entries, and the notice and the radius visible to the person clocking in.

Frequently asked questions

Can we require clock-in on a personal phone?

Requiring personal devices for work is a separate argument, and the sound answer is to offer an alternative: a kiosk at the entrance, a shared computer, a terminal. If the only way to clock in is everybody's own phone, the employer has moved a means of production onto the workforce.

Can we see where somebody is during their shift?

A working-time record does not need it, and what is not needed is not proportionate. Some activities — delivery, home care — have their own justifications, but then it is a different processing operation with its own purpose, notice and impact assessment.

Are fingerprints banned for clock-in?

There is no express blanket ban, but article 9 of the GDPR starts from prohibition, and in time tracking it is very hard to argue that no equally effective, less intrusive method exists. The June 2026 ruling did not change that: it annulled guidance on procedural grounds.

All of this is built into Fichaloto. See how it works.

Keep reading