Fichaloto

Blog Working time

The overtime nobody wrote down

7 min read

Almost no company decides to run overtime. What happens is that in April somebody adds it up and it comes to eighty hours, and by then the window to handle it properly closed two months ago.

Overtime is a subtraction, not a reading

You cannot see overtime by looking at clock-ins. You see it by comparing hours clocked against each person's contractual hours for the same period, net of holiday, absence and public holidays. That subtraction is the only figure needed, and it has to be available all month, not at the end of it.

When the subtraction is not available, overtime is discovered rather than managed. And discovered overtime is always worse: too much of it, all at once, and usually past whatever deadline applied to compensating it.

The Spanish rules, briefly, because they are strict

If any part of the workforce is employed in Spain, five numbers matter. They are stricter than the EU floor and they are enforced.

  • 80 hours a year for a full-time employee, and a collective agreement can lower it.
  • Hours compensated with equivalent paid rest stop counting towards that cap.
  • If neither the collective agreement nor the contract says how to settle them, they must be compensated with rest within four months.
  • Overtime is voluntary unless the collective agreement makes it compulsory, or it is force majeure.
  • It is banned for part-time staff, banned at night outside authorised activities, and banned for under-18s.

The obligation nobody completes

Spanish law asks for three things, not one: record the hours day by day, total them for the period in which they are paid, and give the employee a copy of the summary with the payslip, plus a copy to the works council.

The third is the one that gets skipped, and it is the one that turns an arguable number into an accepted one. A summary handed over every month, never disputed, is the strongest evidence there is that the balance was what you say it was.

The five things worth having on screen

  • A balance per person, visible at any time, with the sign in front of it: owed to the company or owed to the employee.
  • An alert as the cap approaches, per person, months ahead.
  • The deadline on each outstanding bank of hours, as a date rather than a mental calculation.
  • Approval before the fact, even if it is one click. What gets approved in advance does not get argued about afterwards.
  • The monthly summary handed over with pay, generated rather than retyped.

What a year over the cap actually means

Blowing through the annual limit once is a busy quarter. Doing it twelve months running is not a workload spike: it is a hire that was never made, paid for in the most expensive currency available, which is the goodwill of the people who stayed late.

Frequently asked questions

Do hours compensated with time off count towards the cap?

Not in Spain: hours settled with equivalent paid rest drop out of the annual limit. It is the main reason many employers prefer time off to payment.

Can we choose each month whether to pay or compensate?

No. The collective agreement or the contract decides, and if neither does, Spanish law gives you rest within four months. It is applying what was agreed, not picking what suits this month.

What about on-call time?

It depends on what the collective agreement treats as working time. As a rule, time present or actually working counts; mere availability usually does not and tends to carry its own allowance. This is one of the points where the agreement overrides any general rule.

All of this is built into Fichaloto. See how it works.

Keep reading