Fichaloto

Blog Compliance

What failing to keep a Spanish time record really costs

8 min read

The number everybody repeats is wrong, and the one actually in force is smaller than it sounds. The expensive part of having no time record is not the fine: it is what happens afterwards to the burden of proof.

The number, first

Failing to keep the daily working-time record is a serious infringement under article 7.5 of the Spanish Act on Infringements and Penalties in the Social Order, and article 40.1.b sets the range: 751 to 7,500 euros, in three bands.

  • Lower band: 751 to 1,500 euros.
  • Middle band: 1,501 to 3,750 euros.
  • Upper band: 3,751 to 7,500 euros.

It is not per employee

This is the point that gets lost in translation. The penalty is not multiplied by headcount: the number of affected workers is one of the criteria that decide which band applies, not a multiplier. An eighty-person company with no record does not receive eighty fines. It receives one, and it is more likely to land at the top of the range than a six-person one.

The 10,000 euros per worker figure that has been circulating for a year did exist, inside a working-time reduction bill that never made it: Congress returned it to the government on 10 September 2025. It is not in force, and the draft digital-record decree does not touch the amounts either.

What decides the band

The criteria sit in article 39.2, and they read best as what they are: the list an inspector works through before writing a number.

  • Whether there was negligence or intent, and whether there was fraud.
  • Whether earlier warnings or requirements were ignored. This is the one that pushes a report upwards, and the easiest to avoid.
  • Company turnover and the number of people affected.
  • The harm caused.

Repeat offences

Article 41 allows the applicable band to be doubled when the same type of infringement is repeated within 365 days of a final penalty, with a ceiling: never above 7,500 euros. In other words the report has a known maximum, which is exactly why the fine is rarely the part that hurts.

The two bills that are not the fine

Here is the real money, and it is the part that penalty articles leave out.

  • Part-time contracts presumed full-time. If the working time of a part-time employee is not recorded, article 12.4.c of the Workers Statute presumes the contract was agreed on a full-time basis. Back pay and back social security contributions, with surcharges, for every affected contract. That one does multiply.
  • Overtime you cannot disprove. With no record, when somebody claims unpaid overtime your position is "they did not work it" against a notebook, a handful of emails and two colleagues. The record exists mainly for this: not so the employer can watch people, but so the employer can show what happened. Without it, the doubt is resolved against whoever should have kept it.

And the digital-record royal decree?

As of 15 October 2026 it has not been published in the official gazette, so it requires nothing yet. The sequence explains why nobody is sure:

  • 30 September 2025. The Council of Ministers agrees to process it as a separate royal decree, split off from the working-time reduction.
  • 19 March 2026. The Council of State issues an unfavourable, non-binding opinion and calls the draft twenty-calendar-day adaptation period "manifestly insufficient".
  • July and September 2026. Approval is postponed twice.
  • 2 October 2026. The Secretary of State for Labour treats the revision as concluded and points to "the course of October".
  • 5 October 2026. Elections are called for 29 November. That does not block a royal decree, which needs no parliamentary ratification, but it does not help.

What it is expected to require

From the draft, with the caveat that the final text can change: a digital record, remote access for the Labour Inspectorate, traceability of every modification, and each person being able to reach their own data. Those are precisely the four things a spreadsheet cannot do, which is why the adaptation period was the most disputed part of it.

What is already enforceable today

None of this waits for the decree. All of it is enforceable now under article 34.9 of the Workers Statute.

  • A daily record for everybody, part-time and remote staff included.
  • Four years of retention, producible without being reconstructed.
  • Every correction leaving who, when and what it said before.
  • Each person able to see and download their own hours without asking by email.
  • The hours balance closed monthly, not in December.

An honest note

This is a practical guide written by the people who build the tool, with sources checked in the week of publication. It is not legal advice, and a Spanish collective agreement can be stricter than the statute on nearly everything above. For a live inspection or claim, talk to a Spanish employment lawyer.

Frequently asked questions

Is the fine charged per employee?

No. It is one penalty per inspection report, 751 to 7,500 euros, and headcount only helps decide the band. What does repeat per contract is the full-time presumption for part-time staff with no record, which usually costs more than the fine.

What about the 10,000 euros per worker everybody mentions?

Not in force. It was part of the working-time reduction bill that Congress returned to the government on 10 September 2025. The digital-record royal decree, still unpublished, does not change the amounts.

Can an employee be penalised for not clocking in?

The duty to guarantee the record is the employer's, so the report goes to the employer. What the employer can and should do is spot the missed entry, have it corrected through a route that leaves a trail, and treat repetition as the employment matter it is.

How long must the record be kept?

Four years, available to employees, their representatives and the Labour Inspectorate. Available means producible when asked, not merely existing somewhere.

All of this is built into Fichaloto. See how it works.

Keep reading