Fichaloto

Blog Profitability

Fixed fee or time and materials: who carries the risk

7 min read

This is not a commercial preference. It is a decision about who pays if the work turns out to be bigger than anyone thought.

What you are actually choosing

On a fixed fee you commit to an outcome for an amount. Finish early and you earn more; overrun and you absorb it. The estimation risk is entirely yours.

On time and materials — or a prepaid block of hours — you sell capacity the client consumes. If the work runs long, more gets consumed. The risk sits with the client, and in exchange they demand visibility into where it is going.

Everything else — the conversation about trust, about what looks more professional, about what the market expects — follows from that single difference. Worth being clear on it before arguing about anything else.

When to use which

The deciding variable is not project size or client type. It is how well defined the scope is on the day you sign.

  • Fixed fee when you have done this work several times, know your typical variance, and can price it in. Margin comes from efficiency and from having estimated well, and this is where the money is.
  • Time and materials when scope will be discovered as you go, when the client will change their mind, or when third-party dependencies make serious estimation impossible. Fixing a price here is gambling.
  • Blended when part is repeatable and part is open: fix the first, run the second on hours. This is the honest answer for most mid-sized engagements, and the least used, because it sounds complicated to explain.

They need to be controlled differently

This is the part most often skipped: the two models need different numbers to know whether they are on track, and running both the same way is the usual route to finding out too late.

Under fixed fee the number that matters is projected margin: committed value, minus cost consumed, minus estimated cost to complete. You need the price declared, start and end dates, and a progress estimate that is not «about halfway» said from memory.

Under time and materials the number is burn rate against remaining balance. Margin per hour is already fixed in the rate; what kills you is reaching the end of the block with the work unfinished and an awkward conversation ahead. You need balance, consumption, and a projection of when it runs out.

Both need the same thing underneath: the real cost of whoever is doing the work, which is almost never the blended rate everyone uses.

The mistake that costs under both

Billing is not margin. A fixed-fee engagement that bills £40,000 and consumes £38,000 of cost is not a good engagement. It is one that occupied your team for months to leave £2,000, and during those months you could not take anything else.

Opportunity cost never appears in a report, but it is real and it shows up at year end. The way to see it is to measure margin per team hour consumed rather than in absolute terms — that way a large, tight engagement stops looking better than a small, clean one.

Frequently asked questions

Can you switch models mid-engagement?

You can, and sometimes you should, but it only works if you built a scope review milestone into the contract. Switching without having agreed it in advance is asking the client to absorb a risk you sold as yours, and that conversation rarely ends well.

What margin should I target under each?

On time and materials margin is in the rate and it is predictable, so you can work tighter. On fixed fee you need a buffer covering the typical variance for that kind of work: if you historically run 15% over, a 15% target margin is really a zero margin.

How do you handle a block of hours the client never uses?

With an agreed expiry and a consumption report they receive without asking. An open-ended block is an indefinite liability on your side and a guaranteed unpleasant conversation the day they decide to spend it all at once.

All of this is built into Fichaloto. See how it works.

Keep reading